Pre-Diabetes: A lack of Asian – relevant advice
I’m finding it very hard to do anything about my condition.
A bit more about myself:
Female
30 yrs old
BMI = 17.9 ie. Underweight (weight 43kg, height 157cm)
I’m supposed to cut sugars, carbs, fat. Fruits have too much sugar, apparently, so veggies are better.
Arthritis caused by excess uric acid runs in my family – the solution : keep protein intake low.
That means, that I have to cut sugar, carbs, fat, protein.
I get to eat only vegetables.
Drinks wise? I’m allergic to alcohol, lactose-intolerant, highly sensitive to caffeine, and now have to stay away from sugared drinks. All I can have is water.
When somebody like me only has vegetables and water at every single meal, people start demanding that I see a psychiatrist for possible anorexia nervosa. Doesn’t matter that I’m denying it – all anorexics do too!!!
Many of the websites give information based on studies done in Caucasian countries. Even the Singapore based diabetic websites give information that was derived from studies done on Caucasians.
In Caucasian populations (America, Europe, Australia) there is a huge correlation between obesity and diabetes. Consequently, most diabetes-prevention advice has been centered on reducing obesity ie weight- loss. In fact, most websites will tell you that pre-diabetics should aim for a 5 – 10% weight loss.
If I were have a 10% weight loss, I’ll be the same weight I was at 12 years old. That’s freaky.
What epidemiology (ie. The study of the pattern and extent of a disease within populations ) studies have shown, is that Asian (especially East Asians, as opposed to South Asians ie. In Singapore context, Chinese vs Indians) populations tend to have a comparatively low risk for obesity (compared to Caucasians, Hispanics, Africans).
However, they have the highest risk for diabetes. Singapore has one of the highest diabetes rates in the world, exceeding many European nations, and equaling the USA. This is despite us having very low obesity rates compared with Europe and USA.
It’s hard to find such info on diabetes websites – you have to go to the WHO website, or have access to medical journals, which as a developmental biologist, I’m very fortunate to.
Many such epidemiology studies have been on Asian populations — it’s fairly easy to do, and many countries conduct surveys to plan their health policies.
What is severely lacking are research studies finding out the contributing factors of diabetes in Asian people – the risk factors might actually be different enough to warrant a separate set of advice!
Traditionally, the West has taken the lead in research – many Asian nations only started coming into the biotech research industries in the recent years, and even then, it’s limited to a few countries like Japan, Korea, Singapore. Of course, in the West, the focus would be on Caucasians.
So what we really need, is more research into specific Asian populations, where common chronic illness is concerned. Locally, we do have many research groups looking at diabetes, but the funding and push has been focused largely on therapy — stem cells, in particular — simply because that’s where the potential profits are! It doesn’t make business sense to actually do research that comes up with ‘Exercise 6 x 60 mins a week’ as the best cure to diabetes. But such public health research projects are very necessary.
Speaking of exercise. Yes, we’re all supposed to exercise, and I must confess, this is one area I’m severely lacking!
Let’s say I tried to exercise for the recommended 3 sessions a week.
As it is, my schedule is packed. Between being involved in work, writing my thesis, doing NGO projects, meeting friends on a once-in-3-months cycle, I’m barely getting 4 – 6 hours of sleep a day! You know what LKY said about women these days choosing singlehood? Hell, I don’t CHOOSE singlehood! As it is, I have to give up sleep so that I’m not FORCED into singlehood! I have no idea what else I can give up to get exercise.
So it’s well and nice when people give lifestyle advice to tackle health issues — eat a balanced meal, cut this, cut that etc, have enough sleep have enough exercise.
But as long as people in charge of each of life’s domain remain segregated and advice is given out of the context of life in general, all this advice is very very useless!
[...] Healthcare – Mathia Lee: Pre-Diabetes: A lack of Asian – relevant advice [...]
It is quite ironic.
On the one hand, you say people give advice to cut-this-cut-that (this usually mean cut down on excess eating and cut down on ECAs), which essentially is giving your body the time it needs to heal, recover and maintain health.
On the other hand, you say that with all your very packed schedule, you have to give up sleep so that you are not forced into singlehood.
To be blunt about it, you are choosing singlehood and you are choosing to let your condition go worse.
Think about it…
1) Your blog put together is probably thicker than your thesis.
2) And why get involve with ECAs if you are not born with above average physique to take on so many tasks? Unless you are terminally ill, it’s not going to make sense for you to wreck your body into a terminally ill state trying to do so many things.
3) Isn’t research and higher education supposed to get you thinking about how to do more for less?
If you consider the progressive results of letting your condition go worse… You will progressively be able to do less…
Right now you have no idea what to give up in order to do something for your condition…
Later on, your progressively worsening condition will dictate what activities you have to give up.
Not many choices you have.
I am not supposed to give medical advice in the ‘virtual world’, so I’ll try not to give specific advice; nevertheless, I would like to respond to some of your points.
“In fact, most websites will tell you that pre-diabetics should aim for a 5 – 10% weight loss”
*Most*. You need to ask your doctor if that particular piece of advice applies to you.
“What is severely lacking are research studies finding out the contributing factors of diabetes in Asian people”
That is untrue. There is plenty of research on say Chinese populations, looking at liefstyle, environmental, and even genetic factors. Do a search on the Pubmed site. Granted the full articles are not always available for free, but the abstracts usually are, even if they are not always easy to understand. Again, discuss with your doctor if you find something you would like to know more about.
“It doesn’t make business sense to actually do research that comes up with ‘Exercise 6 x 60 mins a week’ as the best cure to diabetes. But such public health research projects are very necessary.”
Ironically, the last sentence of your post contradicts this assertion. We do know that lifestyle modifications can lower one’s risk of diabetes and help control one’s diabetes, but we also know that most people will not do what is required and would rather just take a pill for it.
Your opening sentence shows that you are experiencing a certain amount of stress from your condition; this is not uncommon as a diagnosis of pre-diabetes requires a patient to modify his or her lifestyle and/or to adopt certain coping strategies. I advise you discuss this with your doctor so he/she can identify which specific areas you have problems with and help you with them accordingly.
[...] Healthcare – Mathia Lee: Pre-Diabetes: A lack of Asian – relevant advice [...]
It would be helpful if a list of asian foods with their respective glycemic indices could be compiled by a research project.
oh certainly!!! i hope someone does this! Or puts it up, if they know of its existance