Mathia Lee ~ Plans and Preoccupations

HIV Travel Restrictions – Fright & prejudice

Posted in Life and Death, Sexuality, Social Commentary by mathialee on November 28, 2012

A couple of years ago, someone contacted me through this blog, because her friend, a 21yr old young man, was admitted to hospital for HIV-related complications. She was trying desperately to get help to save his life, but there was little to be done by that late stage. She told me he had not sought help early, despite KNOWing he was HIV positive, because he was Malaysian, and he needed to keep his job as a hairdresser in singapore . He didn’t want authorities to know his status and get deported back home, where he wouldn’t be able to face his family, and so he had refused to go to any doctors. Until he collapsed and had to be admitted into hospital, that is. 2 weeks later, he died.

Very recently, my friend told me about a friend of his, who got stopped at the immigration when he was trying to enter Singapore. This person had businesses and friends and family here, but he was a foreigner. So he cannot even come back to settle all this business. This made my friend very afraid, because my friend is a Malaysian who has been staying in Singapore for very long, with his job and friends and life here. He is afraid to go back to Malaysia to visit family, in case he cannot return. And he has planned, in the event he has to go to Malaysia to visit, to take enough money and be prepared for a scenario where he gets stopped at the immigration and is never allowed to return. The prospect of losing my friend and never seeing him again this way, saddens me. The fact that he has to live his life in fear this way, saddens me more.

 

 

In Singapore, the Immigration Act Subsection 8 includes in its list of prohibited immigrants, “any person suffering from Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome or infected with the Human Immunodeficiency Virus”. Apparently “authorities justified the policy as being necessary to “safeguard the public health of Singaporeans” and to “prevent the import of cases of AIDS and HIV infection into Singapore where it can”.”(http://www.afa.org.sg/act/23/frame_keepingfamily.html )

Someone ignorant, fearful and prejudiced can quite easily believe that we have no choice, but to let some HIV positive non-citizens suffer, for the sake of the greater good. After all, in the early days of the HIV epidemic, many countries reacted the same way, and enacted travel restrictions against immigrants with HIV. However, over the years, evidence has showed that travel restrictions do NOT protect the local population at all. In fact, it can be counter-productive, when migrant workers fear to go for HIV tests , or fear to go for treatment after an anonymous HIV test (as with the young man who died from lack of treatment). This increases the population’s risk, because someone who is unaware of his/her HIV status, or untreated, may not take precautions with their partner (eg to prevent their wife from becoming “suspicious”). Their higher viral load makes them more likely to spread the infection to their partner.

Articles in medical journals have denounced travel restrictions, with headlines such as “Border restrictions and HIV / AIDS: a public health policy disaster.” ,and concluding that “border restrictions based on HIV testing are counter productive and impede efforts to contain the pandemic”. Way back in 1990, the Lancet declared “HIV and travel, no rationale for restrictions.”  Seldom do scientists and medical journals use such strong words, but in this case, they have chosen to. ( http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1978061 , http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12286989 )

Such evidence led countries like the USA and even China, to remove their travel restrictions against people who were HIV positive (http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/united-states-ends-22-year-hiv-travel-ban/story?id=9482817#.ULYmmSpXvhI , http://www.aidsmap.com/China-repeals-its-HIV-travel-ban/page/1438602/ ). The UNAIDS has listed “Eliminate travel restrictions” as one of its key 2011 Political Declaration commitments.

 

 

A strategy that’s gaining support for its effectiveness is the “test and treat” strategy, where regular testing and early detection is encouraged, so that HIV infections can be treated aggressively before symptoms appear. Data showing that it slows or reverses the HIV infection rates, have been encouraging. (http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100224/full/4631006a.html ).  Both HIV testing and affordable, accessible treatment is important for this strategy to work.

In Singapore, we too have embraced HIV testing.  As World AIDS Day approaches, we have set for ourselves a goal of “walking towards zero infections, zero deaths, zero stigma and discrimination” (http://www.aidswalk.sg/ ), modelled after the global goal set out by the UNAIDS.

The Action For AIDS Be Positive video is very supportive and a good step toward eliminating stigma. It also encourages HIV testing, presumably for early treatment, so that people with HIV can live healthy, productive, happy lives, like anyone who has a well-managed chronic disease, so that we can move towards zero deaths.

Unfortunately, with the travel restrictions still enforced, not on the basis of evidence, compassion or effectiveness, but on the basis of ignorance, the truth is that many will be tested, not for treatment, but for deportation, or for a life of hiding and fear.

 

With a prejudice-driven policy of not subsidising HIV medications the way medications for other chronic diseases are subsidised, treatment after testing becomes compromised.

As long as such policies remain, AFA’s call to HIV testing and early treatment, no matter how compassionately done, will sadly continue to be seen as opportunities to pin the scarlet letter onto people living with HIV.

Formation of the Singapore Interfaith Network on Aids

Posted in Global Affairs, Life and Death, religion, Sexuality, Social Commentary by mathialee on November 22, 2011

“The Singapore Interfaith Network on Aids (SINA) was formed recently by an inter-religious group concerned with the issue of HIV/Aids. It has established links with of a cluster of similar networks and together form the Asian Network on Aids (AINA) with Dr Erlinda Senturias as Consultant. It works in collaboration with  the regional office of United Nations programme on Aids (UNAIDS) in Bangkok. These initiatives were made by the Rev Dr Yap Kim Hao, former Bishop of The Methodist Church in Malaysia and Singapore and General Secretary of the Christian Conference of Asia who attended the recent International Congress on Aids in Asia and Pacific (ICAAP) in Busan, Korea.
.
.

SINA seeks to bring together those who are involved in providing faith-based services to people living with Aids in order to develop a more wholistic approach. Effective anti-retroviral medication are being supplied to needy Aids patients, counseling and support are given to them and their families and a shelter is provided for the homeless stricken with Aids. We can do more and we must do more. Appeals will be made especially to more religious people and institutions to address this public health issue which is a threat to all – regardless of religion, race, gender, sexual orientation and socio-economic status. It has become a pandemic in our world and we are reminded of it on World Aids Day in December 1.SINA recognizes the urgent need of prevention of further spread of HIV through wider education including safe sex education in raising the consciousness of people. This HIV awareness will lead to caring for those who are afflicted, removing the stigma of the disease and eradicating discrimination of those with HIV/Aids.
.
.

The Ministry of Health has given the following report:
“In 2012, another 441 Singapore residents were newly reported with HIV infection. About 91% of the new cases were males and 9% were females. This brings the total number of Singaporeans living with HIV to 4,485 as of end 2010. As at 31 Dec 2010, 2,319 are asymptomatic carriers, 1,137 have or have had Aids related illness and 1,389 have died…

.
.

Of the 441 cases reported in 2010, 432 cases acquired the infection through the sexual route, with heterosexual transmission accounting for 52% of infections, homosexual transmission 37% and bisexual transmission 9%, intravenous drug use(4 cases) accounted for 1% of infections…
.
.

Over half (55% of all new cases reported in 2010 were aged between 30 to 49. years of age. Approximately 62% were single, 29% were married and 7% were divorced or separated.”
.
.

Our society has identified more than 4,485 people living with Aids now. They have been  tested positive and 54% are already at a late stage of infection when tested. Thousands more live in denial and even afraid to go for testing for fear of losing their jobs and home and separation from their families and friends.
.
.

One such victim known only by the name of John lamented:”But my life changed when I was diagnosed as being HIV positive. I lost my job. With no income, I had to sell my flat to my siblings so that I could get some cash in hand to obtain treatment and HIV medication. My relationship with my family became strained when they found out about by HIV status. They chased me out of the house, the very same house in which we had all lived happily before. I had nowhere to go. I wandered around aimlessly and lived on the streets and beaches.” – John
.
.

Jacinta Rajoo in drawing our attention to John in her article in The Catholic News questioned us:
“So why are HIV/AIDS sufferers treated with such disdain? Why are they dealt the double or triple blow of not only being afflicted by this disease but also the pain of losing both material and financial freedom, or worst of all, their emotional and social support? “

.
.
It is generally known that Aids though contagious and incurable at the moment is just as death-threatening as other major diseases like cancer. With early detection and treatment people with Aids can live long and useful lives like the rest of us. We have the obligation to support and help one another.

.
.
Hillary Clinton early this month reported that:
“AIDS has killed 30 million people around the world, and 34 million are living with HIV today. In Sub-Saharan Africa—where 60 percent of the people with HIV are women and girls—it left a generation of children to grow up without mothers and fathers or teachers. In some communities, the only growth industry was the funeral business.”

.
.
She issued an appeal to Americans to usher in an Aids-free generation. This is a distinct possibility for all countries with the advance of medical science and social responsibility.

.
.
The worldwide call of UNAids is to “Get Together to Zero” – Zero tolerance of new Infections, Zero tolerance of Aids-related Deaths, Zero tolerance of Stigmatization and Discrimination.

It is achievable. It can be done. Together we can do it.”

.
.

– I received the above press release from Rev Yap today.

In Oct this year, I , as a volunteer with the group Explorations Into Faith, helped organise an Interfaith dialogue on Faith & the response to the HIV/AIDS pandemic. Hosted by Rev Gabriel Liew and the Kampong Kapor Methodist Church, the formation of this network, some initiatives it could take up, were some items discussed. Oct’s dialogue also brought together many people interested in the area of Faith & HIV, whom I believe have become key contributors to the SINA. Am really happy that Rev Yap & the SINA members have taken the initiative to tap on the resources & large following of different religious groups to help people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) in Singapore.  While the much-needed material support like drugs, shelters, counselors, support groups can definitely be provided by NGOs, religious organizations quite “easily” once they put their minds to it, I hope that the stigma surrounding HIV/AIDS can also be addressed. Hopefully, by engaging & educating religious leaders, their followers can also be influenced, since religious leaders are highly respected and believed here in Singapore.

If anyone has any interest in being part of the group, or if you know of anyone , or would like to recommend any of your religious leaders/staff (or even staff of religious schools), please feel free to contact me. If you know of anyone who can be helped by the Interfaith Network (not just for material support, by say, to speak with family members etc) , do contact me as well. There are people of all the major religious groups in Singapore within the SINA who would be most willing to help.

HIV/AIDS situation in Singapore – Sep2011

Posted in Book Review, Life and Death, Sexuality, Social Commentary by mathialee on September 21, 2011

Inst of Policy Studies Sept2011 publication on the HIV/AIDS situation in Singapore.

“Concern for HIV as a personal risk and a threat to public health have declined over the years despite a worsening trend of HIV infection…. Former US Surgeon General, Dr Everett Koop said that HIV was ‘no longer on the public’s radar screen and the result is deadly serious’. His comments could apply to Singapore”

Recommended film : Living With The Tiger

Posted in Book Review, Life and Death, Social Commentary by mathialee on September 19, 2011

Would like to recommend an upcoming film in the Singapore International Film Festival

Living with the Tiger (www.livingwiththetiger.com )
is a real-life feature film about a group of innocent children that are paying a desperate price for the mistakes of others. They have all lost their parents; been born with a life-threatening disease, and most were cast aside to die by extended family. Yet, despite their predicament, they show a resilience and determination that has been inspiring audiences and changing attitudes.

The film-makers aim to raise awareness of the stigma surrounding HIV and the devastating effect it has on peoples lives.

The Nation newspaper said “it has such powerful important messages, it should be mandatory viewing”,  while Greg Lowe from CNNgo described it as “hugely empowering and uplifting”

If you have to miss this screening because you can’t make it, but would really really like to catch it, there’s another chance to do so, as there will be a screening on Monday 26th at NUS.

Clinic giving free facials to raise funds for girl who got HIV at dentist

Posted in Life and Death, Social Commentary by mathialee on December 8, 2010

Some of you may have read the story of a Malaysian girl & another whom doctors think might have contracted HIV from their dental treatments. ( Story here & also reproduced in comment below http://www.asiaone.com/print/Health/News/Story/A1Story20101108-246277.html  ).

The clinic mentioned in the article, Dr Tan Kok Kuan, is currently raising funds for her by giving away free facials. I’m reproducing the email Dr Tan has sent to me here, so that you can read his invitation for yourself, and contact his clinic if you are interested. I had a chance to meet & lunch with Dr Tan too, where we exchanged lots of interesting info & ideas . I personally think it’s wonderful that profit-driven clinics are also getting involved in the business of caring for patients both financially & physically. :

 

From: kok kuan tan <>
To: mathia lee <mathialee@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, 7 December 2010 08:32:26
Subject: Re: hi

hi mathia,

yes. because of the good response we are extending the donation drive till end
dec.
we will also be working with world vision to see what else we can do to help
less fortunate women and children.

did not go for the aids conference but will be participating in a think tank to
educate heterosexual men and women on hiv/aids.

kk

—– Original Message —-
From: kok kuan tan <>
To: mathia lee <mathialee@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, 26 October 2010 15:02:40
Subject: hi

Hi!

Thanks for the lunch company and great conversation.

Forgot to tell you that we are having a fund raising drive in November for that
poor girl I told you about.

Details below.

Hope to count on your support and help spread the word.

Thanks!

kk

JOIN US FOR A MONTH OF CHARITY AND LOOKING FABULOUS!
 
For the entire month of November, Dr. Tan & Partners @ OUB is giving away
medical facials worth as much as $350 absolutely free!
 
This is part of our efforts to raise funds for one of our patients (read her
story below) and to commemorate World AIDS Day which falls on 1st December 2010.
 
Choose from our selection of top grade medical facials including Acne control,
Anti aging, Pigmentation Treatment and Brightening. Lie back, enjoy and let us
pamper you!
 
A donation, however big or small, after the treatment will be much appreciated.
Proceeds will go to helping S get back on her feet.
 
Help us spread this message to your friends and family. Help us put some hope
back into a person’s life.
 
Call 65366418 for an appointment now!
Or get an appointment via our website at http://www.drtanandpartners.com
 
 
The story of Ms. S
 
I saw S in October this year. I can’t tell you her name because she has HIV.
 
S is in her 20’s. She has never had a boyfriend. She has never had sex. She has
never used drugs. So how did she get HIV? She got infected through a visit to
the dentist in her hometown. She was trying to save some money for her elderly
grandmother so she looked for the cheapest option to fix her toothache. Little
did she know about the terrible consequence of this until she went for her Work
Permit renewal where she was required to undergo a HIV test. That was how she
found out the awful truth.
 
Now she has lost her job. She has no way to take care of her elderly
grandmother. She has lost all hope for a family of her own. She has lost all
hope for her future.
 
There is no cure for HIV. But it is a controllable, albeit chronic, disease.
With the proper medical care, S can lead a long and healthy life.
 
I hope that you can join me in helping S get back on her feet again and take
that first step on her long and arduous road to a life as normal as she can make

it.
 
Thank you for your generosity.
 
Dr Tan Kok Kuan
World AIDS Day
1st December 2010

Tagged with: , ,

AIDS and Al-Jazeera?

Posted in Social Commentary by mathialee on April 14, 2010

http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC100407-0000079/mio-TV-drops-Al-Jazeera

Mio Drops Al-Jazeera

I received a comment that I thought I should highlight in a post of its own.

Not sure if you have seen this documentary on the poor treatment of AIDS sufferers in Singapore by Al Jeezera:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LYAaxoRISfM

One activist Stuart Koe went on to say that things are done underground, AIDS patients get their medicine through ‘buyers club’ and people work as ‘mules’ to bring the drugs in from developing countries.

Al Jeezera has been dropped by SingTel’s Mio so Singaporeans will not get to watch their reports anymore on TV.

The documentary was broadcasted on either 3 April or 4 April 2010….Al Jazeera was dropped by SingTel on 1 April so most Singaporeans did not get to see it.

Al Jazeera had previously made documentaries about poverty in Singapore and rampant prostitution & streetwalkers in Geylang.

(I haven’t verified the fact; if anyone would like to correct any factual errors, I’ll appreciate if you leave a comment doing so. Thanks!)

Should ambulance paramedics save drink-driver accident victims?

Posted in Life and Death, Social Commentary by mathialee on January 24, 2010

A friend of mine recently became an ambulance paramedic. He’s a devout Muslim and very involved in interfaith work here. I asked him if his experiences as a paramedic influenced his religious thinking and views of life in general. What he shared was very beautiful.

.

Drink-drivers who meet with accidents gave him the most moral-emotional struggles. To him, drink-driving is one of the most stupid and irresponsible things a person can do. When an accident happens, the drink-driver almost always is the cause of it, and is responsible for his own sorry plight.

.

Yet, as an ambulance paramedic, he does his very best to help and treat and save the drink-driver accident “victim”.

.

These experiences, he says, has changed his mindset and taught him that what a person does and deserves, can and often should be separated from how we treat him. Just because the person did something really wrong, and landed himself in huge trouble, doesn’t mean that we should let him suffer and die.

.

It is the plight of the accident victim that determines how the ambulance paramedic should behave, not what the ambulance paramedic thinks of the victim’s actions and responsibilities

.

I thought that was so beautiful.

.

Society has little compassion for conditions like HIV. Why should we subsidise their treatments when they got infected through their promiscuity? Through irresponsible behavior?  These are common responses.

.

Or when a teenager becomes the victim of sexual abuse because she put herself at risk or was careless, how many people have been unsympathetic, saying that she deserved it?

.

How would you feel if you were in an accident and the ambulance paramedic didn’t help you because he thought you put yourself at risk by jaywalking?

.

How would you feel if you had a heart attack and the hospitals didn’t treat you or took away the 80% Class C subsidy, because you were a huge char kway teow or laksa fan?

.

Why do we continue to subsidise people who smoke and people who don’ t exercise?

.

Because who are we to judge? Who are we to pronounce the death sentence on someone?  Like the ambulance paramedic, it is not our place to judge and to punish. We help because we can, because we ought to, because they need it.  At least I think, that’s our role as human beings.

Tagged with: , , ,

HIV — your REAL risk, Part II

Posted in Life and Death, Sexuality, Social Commentary by mathialee on January 21, 2010

HIV prevalence amongst Batam Sex Workers :  ~1 in 6

% Condom use amongst Sg men in Batam : ~ 3 in 10 (7 in 10 at risk!!!!)

% Condom use amongst Sg men abroad with sex workers in general : ~ 1 in 2

% Condom use amongst Sg men with local sex workers in general: ~8-9 in 10

.

.

.

HIV prevalence amongst Bangkok MSM : 1 in 3

% Condom use amongst S’porean MSM with casual partners : 4 in 5
(http://www.msmsexsurvey.com 2009 Fridae.com MSM survey, see the results there)

.

This ongoing Anonymous Asia Internet MSM Sex Survey will help  improve our understanding  of MSM behaviors   http://www.2010aimss.com/

Please help. Please ask your friends to help

The results will give us critical information in understanding why HIV and other sexually transmitted infection rates are rising so quickly in our community, and help us design better programs for you.”
– 2010 AIMSS

.

.

THis is a follow up from the previous article which gives more explanations . Please take a look. http://mathialee.wordpress.com/2010/01/19/hiv-knowing-your-real-risk/

See comments for Abstracts & Citations for the above info.

(I was doing some research as part of my routine work, and came across these figures. I nearly shit in my pants. It’s unethical to not tell. I just HAD to.  Underestimation of risk perception is a huge reason why people still engage in risky sex —- they think it doesn’t happen to them. Condoms are 99% safe. Russian roulette is 5 in 6 safe….. )

HIV – Knowing YOUR real risk

Posted in Life and Death, Sexuality, Social Commentary by mathialee on January 19, 2010

Lots of HIV figures you see in the newspapers are national averages. What you DON”T know, but SHOULD be looking at, are the rates amongst the sub-groups you are having sex with.

‘Cos by averaging the cases across the entire country’s huge population, the HIV rates looks less scary, the countries don’t look so bad. High risk sub-groups are where most of the HIV cases are concentrated in.

.

.

Your risk :

In Asia, MSM (Men who have Sex with Men) are disproportionately affected by HIV. HIV prevalence amongst MSM in Bangkok estimated at 28%. If you went to Bangkok and had unprotected sex with 3  men who have sex with men, at least 1 of them could be HIV+.
.

.

In Sg,  >90% of HIV+ are male.  1/4 these men are/were married. >90% females are/were married. (See diagram)

What does this mean?

.

It means that if you (female or male, married or not) are having sex with a MSM, the statistics alone put you at much higher risk.

.

If you’re having anal sex, (female or male), the biology puts you at a much higher risk.

.

.

.

If you think you can get away by having a young girl or boy, that’s the stupidest assumption to ever make in your life. Yes, even if you’re straight.

.

In Asian cities where the sex workers don’t ask for condoms, half of them can be HIV+. In Batam, 1 in 6 sex workers have HIV. And because people presume younger sex workers are less risky, more people go for the young ones. Hence, HIV prevalence amongst the teen sex workers can be MORE than DOUBLE that amongst those above 20yrs old.

.

.

.

In Sg, ~50% the HIV infections detected only in the late stage. This means that there are probably many more HIV+ people who are very healthy, unaware of their status, and transmitting it if they’re having unprotected sex.

.

That means you could unknowingly spread it to your wife, and by the time you fall ill, it’s been 5 years too late.

.

.

Your life as a consequence

In Dec08, we thought HIV was going to be treated like any other chronic diseases, and generic drugs subsidised (http://mathialee.wordpress.com/2008/12/02/say-yes-to-aids-treatment-subsidies/ )

.

( Health Minister Khaw Boon Wan told The Straits Times he agreed with the view that HIV should be treated ‘like any chronic disease’. ‘The committee of experts will apply the same approach as they do when evaluating drugs for other diseases. We should not single out HIV for special treatment,’ he said. …..  Health Minister asked the Communicable Diseases Centre (CDC) to draw up a list of drugs that should be eligible for subsidies. http://app.mfa.gov.sg/pr/read_content.asp?View,11626,  Full Report in Comments)

.

.

Over the weekend,  we learn that HIV treatments are NOT going to be subsidized. They can now be funded by Medifund.

.

(Offering subsidies for all patients could “open a floodgate”, he noted. While previous media reports pointed to the ministry subsidising HIV medication, MOH told MediaCorp on Friday: “Minister Khaw Boon Wan and MOH did not commit in 2008 to subsidising HIV medication.” “Our stand in 2008 was that HIV should be considered like any other chronic disease when evaluating the suitability of providing subsidies for medications.” “MOH has chosen to use the Medifund route to more flexibly help HIV patients with their bills, including that for anti-retroviral drugs if needed. Doing so allows available funds to be focused to provide appropriate amounts of assistance to the most deserving cases.”  http://www.todayonline.com/Print/Singapore/EDC100116-0000124/Medifund-to-help-needy-Sporeans-who-require-HIV-treatment )

.

.

.

This means that you still have to fork out ~$1200 of your salary each month for HIV treatments. That’s if you keep your job, because there are no laws protecting your job. It means that this (http://mathialee.wordpress.com/2008/11/11/living-with-hiv-in-singapore/ ) could still be your life. When you get to a desperately poor stage however, you can now use Medifund.  Or you can still go to Thailand to get 3-months supply at a time for $100-200 at anytime.

.

.

.

What’s my point? What can you do?.

My point is that, please, just NEVER have unprotected sex. ALWAYS use a condom. Condoms are 99% protective, when used 100% of the time, correctly.

.

.

Please remember, HIV is NOT like other Chronic Diseases (and will NOT be treated as one, in terms of subsidies too).

Why?

.

One cigarette won’t give you lung cancer. One fatty MacDonald’s meal won’t give you a heart attack. One huge glass of coke won’t give you diabetes. You have to screw up again and again, over years and years, by smoking and eating/drinking unhealthily.  

.

.

But HIV is different.

You can do the right thing 99.9% of the time. Use a condom 99% of the time. Be faithful 99% of the time. Probably even abstain 99% of the time.

.

But just one slip-up. One mistake. One moment of carelessness when you were drunk.

.

Just ONCE. And that’s enough. HIV infection is not something you accumulate through years of casual unsafe sex. It’s something you get in a single sex session.

.

.

And for that you pay. You pay with your health, your dignity, and your finances. 

.

.

While the guy next door who ate char kway teow for 50 years and now has a stroke lies in the C class ward with loads of subsidies and sympathy.  

.

.

Life is not fair. The world is not fair. People are not fair.

.

.

.

So don’t let yourself down. You’re the only one who can take care of yourself. Please stay safe, always use a condom (yes, 1 condom, not 2) .

.

.

.

( I would love to ask you to help spread this message.  However, be warned: there will be people who will accuse you of encouraging homosexuality or a gay lifestyle or immorality.  Since male homosexuality is against the law, you may be accused of abetting a criminal act. You may lose your friends.)

.

( Sources: WHO Best Practices publication “HIV and Men who have Sex with Men in Asia and the Pacific”.
-J Infect. 2006 Oct;53(4):255-9. Epub 2005 Dec 27.
-AIDS. 2000 Dec 1;14(17):2731-40.
- MOH http://www.moh.gov.sg/mohcorp/statistics.aspx?id=246 )

STI cases more alarming amongst adults compared to teens

Posted in Sexuality, Social Commentary by mathialee on January 14, 2010

I don’t like how the reporter used this phrase “And 7 in 10 cases involved young adults: Among those under age 20, two-thirds were female, while the opposite was true for those over 20. http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1030606/1/.html
Rise of STIs “especially alarming”, says Health Minister
.
.
.
It reinforces the mistaken believe that teenagers are responsible for most cases, where actually teens make up about 1/10 of cases only only. “Young adults” in health-speak, refer to the 20-40s, who are indeed the bulk of STI patients (7/10 cases) . (rough classification: below 20 children/adolescents, 20-40 young adults, 40-60 middle age, 60-80 young-elderly, 80 on old-elderly. Older adults in general refer to the post-50 or 60)
.
.
This mistaken belief that teens make up 7/10 cases fuels the public pressure for emphasizing abstinence FROM SEX in sex ed. Abstinence is possible perhaps for most teens, but once they get into their 20s and 30s, it borders on the ridiculous. But education is for LIFE , not for NOW
.
.
If people understood the situation, they’ll realise sex ed should be about how to have sex healthily, so that when they are post-20 adults and engaging, they can take care of themselves. Teens who are taught to not have any sex, and are not given enough info, will get to their 20s and 30s engaging in behaviors they believe are healthy, but are in fact not. (eg. using 2 layers of condoms are actually very dangerous, and not safer than just 1)
.
.
Singapore’s public health messages to the public focus on “Abstinence from CASUAL sex”, not “Abstinence” per se, ( http://www.hpb.gov.sg/aids/page3.htm ) which is a far more practical advice we need to educate teens with.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.